Sunday, April 15, 2012

Ouch (saving for future use)

Perry Anderson:
Now laden with as many European prizes as the ribbons of a Brezhnevite general, Habermas is no doubt in part the victim of his own eminence: enclosed, like Rawls before him, in a mental world populated overwhelmingly by admirers and followers, decreasingly able to engage with positions more than a few millimetres away from his own. Often hailed as a contemporary successor to Kant, he risks becoming a modern Leibniz, constructing with imperturbable euphemisms a theodicy in which even the evils of financial deregulation contribute to the blessings of cosmopolitan awakening, while the West sweeps the path of democracy and human rights towards an ultimate Eden of pan-human legitimacy.
I really like The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, but my general sense of his other work is of a mess of terms circling around and away from any real point. And his politics, it seems, have gone entirely off the rails in the last couple decades.

No comments: