Sunday, March 04, 2012

Weber in his existentialist mood


Weber liked to observe that whereas the peasants and lords of the middle ages could think of their life as a well-trodden succession of stations, at the end of which, they would know that they had passed through the entire breadth of what made for a complete life. In the modern age, individuals have the freedom to choose the course of their lives, but for that very reason, what makes up a life becomes unavoidably a matter of choice. There is no longer any standard that says yes, this is a complete life. And so, the modern individual has an almost unlimited menu of “meanings” to attempt to possess, but no matter how much they achieve, there is always room to try to hold one more.

This suggests an extension: The power of artistic form is to be able to have it both ways: it is freely created thing, and yet it is inscribed as a completed thing. Its end is not a cutting off of what could have continued on but marks out a full circuit.

Kind of a nice line of thought. Totally agnostic on whether it's right or not, though.

No comments: